In today's Philosophy class led by Mr. Robert DeCarlo, an engaging activity aimed at deepening students' comprehension of Passage 9 from the Tao Te Ching unfolded. The passage advocates the wisdom of restraint, stating, "[it is] better to stop short than [to] fill to the brim." The lesson conveyed the idea that one should know when to cease rather than persist.

To illustrate this concept practically, Mr. DeCarlo distributed two paper cups to each student—one small and the other slightly larger. Students were told to choose which beverage they wanted the least, and were given the options of milk, water, or orange juice, with most choosing milk. They were then asked to indicate when he should stop pouring the milk into the smaller cups. Irrespective of their chosen stopping points, he filled each cup to the very brim. Following this, students were instructed to consume the entire glass of milk, leading to a discussion on excess consumption, waste, and the ensuing cleanup efforts. The takeaway emphasized the Taoist principle of "stopping when you think it is enough." 

The lesson proceeded as Mr. DeCarlo queried students about their next beverage preference, with many opting for orange juice. This time, when pouring juice into the larger cups, he halted at their request. The ensuing discussion centered on the satisfaction derived from self-regulation, avoiding excess, and the absence of regrets or mess. The lesson aimed to prompt reflection on personal decision-making regarding when "enough is enough."

Expanding the analogy to various scenarios, Mr. DeCarlo linked the lesson to studying, highlighting the futility of pushing beyond the point of effective learning. Drawing parallels to oversharpening a knife and the risk of rendering it useless, he stressed the importance of recognizing when an activity becomes counterproductive.

In relating the exercise to local car thefts, Mr. DeCarlo conveyed the lesson's broader implications. Displaying excess wealth, akin to amassing gold and jade, can attract unwanted attention and compromise one's ability to protect possessions. The overall message echoed the Taoist teaching that discerning when to stop is intrinsic to a harmonious and balanced existence.


In conclusion, Mr. DeCarlo encapsulated the lesson by prompting students to reflect on the broader applications of Taoist principles in their lives. Whether in the pursuit of knowledge, honing skills, or managing possessions, the wisdom of recognizing limits and knowing when to stop resonated throughout the immersive experience. The class left with a deeper understanding that, much like the delicate balance espoused by Taoism, a mindful approach to moderation and restraint can lead to greater satisfaction, purpose, and harmony in their individual journeys.

  • Homepage
  • In the News
  • News
  • homepage news